Advertisement

Phyllis & Her Walk In The Woods Tokaji Cask Finished (Batch Tokaji 1-24)

CAPSULE REVIEW

Classification: Blend of Straight Ryes Finished in Tokaji Barrels

Company: Caledonia Spirits, Inc.

Distillery: Barr Hill Distillery

Release Date: October 2024

Proof: 100

Age: Blend of 3-7 year old rye whiskeys

Mashbill:

-60% | 3 Year | 84% Vermont Rye, 16% Vermont Barley
-20% | 6 Year | 84% Vermont Rye, 16% Vermont Barley
-20% | 7 Year | 84% Vermont Rye, 16% Vermont Barley

Color: Amber

MSRP: $129 / 750mL (2025)

Official Website

NOSE

Malted grain | Burnt brown sugar | Steeped tea | Light stone fruits

palate

Jammy stone fruits | Pretzel dough | Cap’n Crunch cereal | Brown sugar | Youthful undertone | Floral

finish

Baking spices | Rye spice | Toasted oak | Steeped malt tea | Lingering malted grain note

uniqueness
value
overall

A complex finished rye with highlights of stone fruits and a youthful undertone throughout.

Phyllis & Her Walk In The Woods is distilled in Vermont using 100% Vermont grains. The distillery strives to be good stewards of the land, which operates via their registered Landcrafted mission. One of the brands distilled at Barr Hill Distillery, the company started distilling in 2011 using a 15 gallon copper pot still at their location in Hardwick, Vermont, near the Barr Hill Nature Preserve, their namesake. In 2019, the company moved to a new location in Montpelier, where they built out a distillery with increased production capacity.

Phyllis & Her Walk In The Woods Tokaji Cask Finished is the company’s third release in their 2024 series, which includes Phyllis & Her Walk In The Woods Rye Whiskey Double Oaked and Phyllis & Her Walk In The Woods Rye Whiskey Port Cask Finished. Like the other two releases in 2024, Tokaji Finish is a complex whiskey that’s difficult to figure out immediately. It delivers a range of similar flavors to other finished ryes from the distillery, but adds a pleasing layer of stone fruits that’s most evident on the nose and palate. The Tokaji finish is also malty throughout, which is akin to the flavors you would pick up if you have ever experimented with steeping malted grain like a tea. While exploring the complexity of this whiskey is enjoyable and even challenging, the downside is that it has a youthful undertone that’s pervasive throughout, which is likely driven by the 3 year old component that makes up the majority of the blend. Upping the overall age of the blend, or possibly excluding that younger component entirely, could be the key to unlocking this whiskey.

The sample used for this review was provided to us at no cost courtesy its respective company. We thank them for allowing us to review it with no strings attached.
360 video

Written By: Nick Beiter

January 29, 2025
photo of author
Available at these retailers
COMMENTS
Phyllis & Her Walk In The Woods Tokaji Cask Finished (Batch Tokaji 1-24)
Also Check out
No items found.
Reviews By This Author
Recent Reviews
Recent Articles
  • Exclusive Content
  • new content summary
  • bourbon in the news
  • social media roundup
Terms of UsePrivacy PolicyEthics PolicyCommenting Policy