Advertisement

Lost Lantern 2025 Single Cask #20: McCarthy’s Peated Oregon Single Malt 10 Years Old

CAPSULE REVIEW

Classification: American Single Malt

Company: Lost Lantern

Distillery: Sourced from Clear Creek Distillery

Release Date: November 2025

Proof: 118.6

Age: 10 Years

Mashbill: 100% Peated Malted Barley

Color: Dark Amber

SRP: $150 / 750mL (2025)

Official Website

Press Release

WHERE TO BUY
WHERE TO BUY
Lost Lantern 2025 Single Cask #20: McCarthy’s Peated Oregon Single Malt 10 Years Old
from our Trusted Retail Partners:
NOSE

Peat | Smoke | Wet stone | Cinnamon toast | Spice | Black pepper | Blackberry | Raisin

palate

Blackberry | White peach | Seasoned oak | Chocolate

finish

Peat | Campfire smoke | Butterscotch | Vanilla | Leather | White peppercorn | Oak

uniqueness
value
overall

A stunningly rich and high proof single malt, Lost Lantern 2025 Single Cask #20: McCarthy’s 10 Year Old fuses the intense smoke and peat of a scotch with rich, bourbon-like notes, creating a complex "crossover" whiskey rarely seen in American single malts.

McCarthy’s Peated Oregon Single Malt 10 Years Old is part of Lost Lantern’s Fall 2025 Collection, which they refer to as the “Scotch Lover’s Collection,” as it takes a “deep dive into the more traditional side of American single malt.” Clear Creek Distillery, the producer of McCarthy’s is no stranger to Lost Lantern, as they have featured a 6 year old release in 2021 and a 3 year, 11 month old release in 2022.

Clear Creek Distillery is considered one of the first American single malts distilleries having been founded in the 1990s. They are currently owned by Hood River Distillers and continue the McCarthy's whiskey tradition of American single malts that take inspiration from scotch with an emphasis on peat and Scottish barley, but are aged in Pacific Northwest-made oak barrels. According to Lost Lantern, the 2025 Single Cask #20 is first-ever 10 year old McCarthy’s single cask, the oldest whiskey the distillery has ever released.

With American single malts, the term “crossover” appears more often than other types of American-made whiskeys. We’ve used the term multiple times in discussing McCarthy’s whiskeys as they are able to fuse characteristics from both American single malts and scotch. Double digit aged American single malts are still a rarity, and as a result, Lost Lantern 2025 Single Cask #20 offers characteristics not experienced before because of its lengthy aging process.

Age has a profound impact on this 10 year old McCarty’s single malt and it begins with its color. It’s extremely dark for this style of whiskey despite it being aged in a fourth-fill 400-liter Oregon Garryana oak cask. This results in a single malt with a high oak content that features many more traditional bourbon flavors than you typically see. Vanilla, caramel, leather, and chocolate all play roles in this whiskey's flavor profile.

On the flipside, its heavily-peated malted barley is unwavering in its intensity. Big smoke and peat notes dominate this whiskey and aren’t for the faint of heart. Combined with its bourbon-like flavor profile, the result is a whiskey ripe with complexity. Though it loses some of the brightness and grain-focus found in its younger iterations, the dramatic change that a few extra years this whiskey underwent in aging is staggering. If you ever wondered what a cross between a bourbon and scotch would really taste like, this whiskey is your ticket to the main event.

Lost Lantern McCarthy’s Peated Oregon Single Malt 10 Years Old is a 250 bottle release.

The sample used for this review was provided to us at no cost courtesy its respective company. We thank them for allowing us to review it with no strings attached.
360 video

Written By: Eric Hasman

November 14, 2025
photo of author
COMMENTS
Lost Lantern 2025 Single Cask #20: McCarthy’s Peated Oregon Single Malt 10 Years Old
Also Check out
No items found.
Reviews By This Author
Recent Reviews
Recent Articles
  • Exclusive Content
  • new content summary
  • bourbon in the news
  • social media roundup
Terms of UsePrivacy PolicyEthics PolicyCommenting Policy